Beverley Mitchell Mandy Taylor Jason Frederick Zach Barran Ryan Buggle Caleb Taylor Eliza Roberts Darla Jean Johnson William Ragsdale Mayor Jeff Mugga Jasmine Stephanie Andujar Blanca Avila Al Sapienza Colonel Gibson Alicia Minshew Bonnie Cara Maria Sorbello Trixie Jim E. Chandler Bandleader Kenney Myers Larry Catherine Cain Jonesborough Resident Noah Mendes Stanley Anthony Pallino Sam Alexa Sapienza Annie Donna Drake Ms. Osborne Monika Mannix Jonesborough Resident Mike Tumminello Fair Goer Erica Matz Sweetie Pie's Patron Zach Walker Sweetie Pie's Patron Kirsten Calhoun Jonesborough Resident Joseph Pisani Delivery Guy Gregory Partsinevelos Texan #1 Gavin Cruz Ice Cream Man