Jesse Eisenberg Ralphie Adrien Brody Dan Odessa Young Sal Philip Ettinger Jason Sallieu Sesay Ahmet Evan Jonigkeit Son Brad Caleb Eberhardt Son Aaron Ethan Suplee Dad Leo Lamar Johnson Garfield Gheorghe Muresan Sachiel Brian Anthony Wilson Zander Sean Edward Lewis Son Cy Brian Brehm Son Drew Blake Brehm Son Paul Adam Wade McLaughlin Jerome Matthew Lamb Raymond Rheta West Tammy Jonah Wharton Connor Garrett Richmond Blake Zia Anger Alice Jack Jones Young Ralphie Ben Smith-Petersen Officer Michael Mike Alamo Pawn Shop Owner Sheila Trasente Waitress Barbara Ackerman Cashier