Susan Sarandon Adele August Natalie Portman Ann August Hart Bochner Josh Spritzer Eileen Ryan Lillian Ray Baker Ted John Diehl Jimmy Shawn Hatosy Benny Bonnie Bedelia Carol Faran Tahir Hisham Badir Elisabeth Moss Rachel John Carroll Lynch Jack Irwin Caroline Aaron Gail Letterfine Paul Guilfoyle George Franklin Mary Ellen Trainor Homeowner Ashley Johnson Sarah Corbin Allred Peter Eva Amurri Girl on TV Heather DeLoach Ellen Stephanie Niznik Waitress Heather McComb Janice Pearlman Lindley Harrison Janice's Mother Michael Milhoan Cop Samantha Goldstein 4 Year Old Ann Nina Leichtling Josh's Wife